Skip to content

Salon I: End-to-End Encryption in ActivityPub - 2024 Protocol Symposium

TalkEvan Prodromou, Tom Coates
researcheracademic
Salon I: End-to-End Encryption in ActivityPub - 2024 Protocol Symposium
Open resource →

Evan Prodromou and Tom Coates present their Summer of Protocols research on integrating end-to-end encryption into ActivityPub, arguing that the fediverse's low-trust server operators and high-risk user base (LGBTQ users, activists, infosec community) make E2E encryption necessary despite the protocol's original email-like trust assumptions. They explain why they chose Messaging Layer Security (MLS) over alternatives like PGP, Signal's protocol, or OTR—citing MLS's royalty-free IETF standard status and scalability—and propose a new ActivityPub extension adding a key store and groups mechanism, while Coates details UI challenges around key management, archive restoration, and segregating encrypted from unencrypted messages.

Topics

activitypub-extension-designend-to-end-encrypted-archive-restorationmessaging-layer-security-mlsprotocolspublic-key-encryptionkey-management-uiresearchsignal-protocol-vs-mls-tradeoffssymposium-2024technology

Related resources

Talk

Salon V: Autonomous Realities - 2024 Protocol Symposium

Amber Hu presents research on 'autonomous realities,' the fragmentation of shared experience as personalized mixed-reality (AR/VR) devices proliferate, and proposes a 'decentralized digital chemistry' framework using self-sovereign identity (DIDs) and object capabilities to let people merge disparate mixed-reality worlds when they physically encounter each other. The talk also introduces multi-party computation and private set intersection as a protocol for detecting mutual interest in merging realities before an encounter, illustrated by a planned art piece called 'Quantum Masquerade' for Defcon. Attendees including Dorian and others raise engineering concerns about decentralized access control and cultural parallels to etiquette-based reality negotiation.

Amber Hu

Talk

Divergent Protocols: A Speculative Protocol for Cultural Convergence Zones

Nicolás Madoery presents 'divergent protocols' as a counter-model to standard protocols that converge toward homogenization, arguing that AI and robotics now function as infrastructure (not tools) through which culture becomes 'liquid' and infinitely re-versioned. Drawing on examples like AI-generated Argentine folklore, a dancing folk robot, and his PIACH framework for cultural organizations, he proposes protocols that preserve diversity by naming what is lost, keeping source names, and leaving room for noise rather than optimizing transmission.

Nicolás Madoery

Talk

Markets and the Journey to Neutrality

Nicholas Fett traces the history of market neutrality from 1889 Oklahoma land runs and Adam Smith's moral sentiments through Keynes, the Mont Pelerin Society, and into crypto, arguing that protocols designed to be neutral (Bitcoin's decentralization, Ethereum's 'crops' ethos) inevitably get captured by economic incentives like mining and block-builder centralization. He uses the 'tunnel' and 'one more lane' analogies to argue that building for neutral principles without a defined societal goal leads to outcomes divorced from original intentions, and that protocol designers must instead encode explicit purpose rather than chase an unattainable neutral equilibrium.

Nicholas Fett